Last week Reform lost a by-election. That in itself isn’t really news. Reform, from the outset, have had mixed results in defending by-elections and quite often lose a seat not long after winning (though they have also had a fair amount of success winning by-election seats from other parties).
So, it’s understandable that these exchanges are mainly of interest to political geeks (like me) who endlessly stare at the weekly results in the hope to draw out some glimpse of the future.
However, with talk of Andy Burnham’s team at least considering a potential early election, you can bet that somewhere in the bowels of Labour Party HQ there is someone equally geeky pouring over results to work out how Britain’s new five party political system could play out if a general election was called today.
And it’s this final point that makes the Shepshed result so intriguing! For Labour beat reform by just 53 votes. Now reform are firmly blaming this defeat on the inclusion of a Restore candidate who got 228 votes – and on the face of it, that’s entirely true
But dig into the history of this seat over the last decade (since it was reorganised in 2017) and a more nuanced and potentially profound picture emerges.
| 2017 | 2021 | 2025 | 2026 | |
| Conservative | 1,836 | 2,051 | 1,054 | 819 |
| UKIP/Reform | 364 | 1,859 | 1,110 | |
| Restore | 228 | |||
| Labour | 1,095 | 946 | 742 | 1,163 |
| Liberal Democrat | 213 | 177 | 276 | 115 |
| Green | 87 | 239 | 211 | 112 |
I tend to look at votes rather than percentages, and in this case, it helps to explain how this seat has changed hands. This is even more pronounced when you split the vote into a left/right divide:
| Right | 2,200 | 2,051 | 2,913 | 2,157 |
| Left | 1,395 | 1,362 | 1,229 | 1,390 |
There are two stories at play here. Firstly (and one we are more familiar with) is the fragmentation of the vote on the right. There is no doubt that Shepherd is a right leaning seat with around 60-70% of the vote going to right leaning parties. Before the arrival of Reform, that meant a safe seat for the Conservatives.
In 2025, Reform took the seat from the Conservatives as the right vote split and a surge in Reform popularity boosted their overall vote. Roll forward 12 months and Restore appear on the ballot, resulting in the right vote sub-dividing again.
But that story, in itself, didn’t cost Reform the seat, and here is where it gets interesting.
Historically 1,110 votes would have (just) been enough to win. But Labour managed to do something that would normally be seen as surprising for an incumbent government party. Instead of disillusioned Labour voters sub-dividing into Lib Dems or the Greens, the Labour party managed to squeeze nearly half both party’s vote into their column – and as a result get them over the winning line.
And therein potentially lies the glimpse into the future. For currently, Labour election strategists will be trying to design a pathway that gets them back to power in the new world order of 5/6 party politics – and Shepshed might have just demonstrated how that could happen.
If the right remains divided between 3 (unequal) party blocks, and Labour can squeeze the left into their column, then suddenly a second GE election win doesn’t seem impossible – despite Labour polling below 30%.
However, there are number of key factors that need to continue to be in play for this strategy to succeed
- Reform needs not to regain its mojo.
Reform has lost its momentum, and there’s a sense that voters are either fans or want to keep them out. Farage is particularly marmite, and this is potentially dangerous if voters become more motivated to block Reform from power (see Le Pen in France) than they are by traditional party loyalty.
- The Conservatives need to remain stalled
While much of the right-wing press and party members have come to see Kemi as a strong leader of a united party, voters seem less forgiving of the Conservative brand overall – leaving a party that has probably avoided the extinction moment, but equally its nowhere near regaining voters’ trust at the level required to win
- Restore need to stand everywhere
Restore are a Reform problem, and it seems very personal at all levels. If Restore stand, they do damage to Reforms vote – and in a 5/6-way split, this will be enough to deny Reform wins – but how many seats can they realistically stand in?
- Andy Burnham needs to remain the “Saviour”
Burnham’s narrative of the “saviour” of the left is a very deliberate (and clever) ploy which has meant that he has managed to reset the Labour party as the primary party of the left. This is allowing Labour to be seen as the firewall against Reform in particular. But being in power means taking difficult decisions, and the risk for Burnham is that the longer he is there, the more tarnished his “Saviour” brand becomes.
- Greens and the Lib Dems need to continue to have ineffective leaders
Polanski has managed to implode in spectacular fashion, trapping the Greens in the meantime in a potential political cul-de-sac. The Lib Dems face a similar crisis. Ed Davey was picked because he was inoffensive (and allowed them to return to their ground game). But now his stunts are undermining the Lib Dem brand, bringing into question what the party actually stands for, which could be dangerous in a more crowded political marketplace.
The result in Shepshed does demonstrate a potentially winning path for Labour, however that path is narrow, with a potentially small window of opportunity and not without considerable risk.
But it does explain why talk of an early election isn’t entirely without merit. So, the question for Labour strategists is, do they take the risk now or wait to see if a more favourable path emerges?
While I’m still betting on Andy Burnham sticking it out to 2029, don’t be surprised if he suddenly marches off to the palace – because it might actually be strategically the smartest move there is.